Amanda Vance the Hottest Sports Handicapper?

Amanda Vance may not be the first former NFL Miami Dolphins cheerleader turned sports handicapper (that honor belongs to Lisa Perry, the one time Indianapolis Colts cheerleading captain turned Gambling911.com sports handicapper).

Currently, Vance is the hottest sports handicapper (in more ways than one).

Yeah, move over Taylor Mathis.

When she’s not giving her football takes, Vance is dropping thirst trap photos to her more than 536,000 Instagram followers.

Pro sports bettor Rob Pizzola is not impressed with Vance's recent hot streak.

"Someone flips a coin a thousand times, they're gonna get a streak of heads ten in a row.  It's gonna happen," he says.

I logged onto twitter and saw all this discourse about @amandacvance. I checked out her website and spotted a red flag that most people wouldn't know to look for. pic.twitter.com/tSGhdjrdbq

— Rob Pizzola (@robpizzola) February 14, 2025

Pizzola points to Vance's website FAQ section that suggests "this person is probably not going to win betting on sports".

He notes that she only makes her plays during the period 5 pm and 6 pm each day, unless there is an early game.

"Look at the betting markets between 5 and 6 pm Eastern Time for major sports or props or whatever.  They're mostly dead every single day.  There is a reason why they are mostly dead.  Groups battle it out over the course of the day.  They go back and forth.  There's news information over the course of the day, usually earlier.  People bet it.  By that time the market has mostly settled and people are just waiting until closer to game time to make sure there's not some type of hidden news, stuff they don't know about, so you rarely see a ton of action in the betting markets from 5 to 6 pm.

"So for someone to say they release their picks around that time, it is pretty much a dead giveaway that they are not going to win."

He adds that "she either finishes her handicapping around that time or just doesn't understand how the markets work.  It took me three minutes to figure this out."

The original NFL cheerleader-turned sports handicapper, Gambling911.com's Lisa Perry

Apparently there has been a lot of discourse over Amanda Vance of late, according to Pizzola.

But Pizzola's followers weren't exactly buying into his theory.

Mike writes:

"I wait for the market to settle to make my plays. The line movement is telling to me.  So I don’t think anything of her releasing her picks at that time.  I’ve just never seen her have a losing day. That’s what I question."

Jeffrey Benson of Circa Sports tweeted:

"(Rob) Can you lower the camera a bit? We need to see more than just your face if you want to be a sbinfluencer."

RobDFS offered:

"Seems like you’re just a #hater !!"

And Mike Vivian:

"SHOW US YOUR CHEST!"

Vance wasn't taking any of it to heart.

"On my dinner date right now have to remind the haters I won again."

She also added that "I'm too drunk to care".

On my dinner date right now have to remind the haters I won again. ( shit on my reasoning but it’s cropped out and I’m too drunk to care) https://t.co/qjIMqv855i pic.twitter.com/8S549JBdQG

— Amanda Vance (@amandacvance) February 15, 2025

Mr. J responded to Amanda:

"Damn you must be able to retire since you never lose a bet."

"Villain energy. I love it. All the other women handicappers are too bubblegum sweet.  Amanda going full villain and I’m here for it."

Amanda claimed the other day that Patrick Mahomes was in talks with the Pittsburgh Steelers.

"Source, Me," she wrote on Twitter.

To which PhD Big Yak quipped:

"BREAKING NEWS: Amanda Vance proposes to me after Chiefs Super Bowl loss!!!!! Source: My Dreams."